Urban Decay 24/7 or MAC Powepoint Eye pencial ?

[julayyx33]

Which eyeliner is better, if you haven't used one of these eyeliners.. what eyeliner would you recommend that doesn't smudge? (Pencial eyeliners please) =]

[JaneaBug]

I love them both actually. Urban Decay is nice and soft and you can use pencils as a shadow too if you blend them. MAC is just awesome!!! But Too Faced has ones that don't smudge.

[julayyx33]

I love them both actually. Urban Decay is nice and soft and you can use pencils as a shadow too if you blend them. MAC is just awesome!!! But Too Faced has ones that don't smudge.

LOL well outta the two which would you recommend most? The MAC is about 2 dollars cheaper than the Urban Decay, but they are the same size? Do any of them smudge ?

[punkybitch]

urban decay smudge a bit but tbh most do. urban decay is bright and funky and i think gives an overall original look

[JaneaBug]

LOL well outta the two which would you recommend most? The MAC is about 2 dollars cheaper than the Urban Decay, but they are the same size? Do any of them smudge ?

If you let them dry long enough they will last and not smudge. I usually use a small angled brush and smudge it a bit anyway. I use MAC more. They don't smudge as much as Urban Decay. But if you really don't want smudge Too Faced. You have options. I live in Florida where it's hot so it's hard not to have smudge hehe!

[Calizona]

Before I started using Urban Decay's 24/7 eyeliners I would end up looking like a raccoon an hour after I put it on. I live in the California desert and make-up used to just run off me. When it comes to make-up with staying power, price is not an issue unless you are planning to buy every single color. You can smudge UD when you are putting it on for the smoky look, but once it sets, it stays! I can't say anything about Mac cosmetics as I haven't used them.

[Marcilly]

Personally, I don't think a smudge-proof pencil exists. Heat and the oils from your skin will eventually win. (Both are major contributors to smudging/creasing eye makeup) I've never tried the Urban Decay 24/7 Eye Liners but I have used MAC Powerpoint and they wear really well. I've had smudge-free success for up to 6 hours. It helps to dust a little Blotting Powder around the eye area after your eye makeup application.

[julayyx33]

Thanks everyone!

[ali_gator13]

Personally I would say Urban Decay, but I prefer Makeup Forever eyeliner. It's amazing.